Mathematics
The maths that tells us when a scientific discovery is real – or not
When huge scientific discoveries are made, you may hear that they are “statistically significant” or pass a threshold called “5 sigma” – but those calculations can be manipulated to make claims seem grander than they are, finds Jacob Aron
By Jacob Aron
8 May 2025
Facebook / Meta
Twitter / X icon
Linkedin
Reddit
Email
The most common tools for assessing the rarity of a finding still require plenty of assumptionsShutterstock / Kenishirotie
Terry Pratchett was fond of saying that million-to-one chances crop up nine times out of ten. On the face of it, this sentence is mathematically absurd, but in the fantasy world of Pratchett’s Discworld books, powered by the magic of narratives, it makes perfect sense. Of course heroes are always going to face incredible odds, and of course they are almost always going to overcome them, because that is what heroes do.
Read moreWhy the long history of calculating…
Advertisement
if (window.adverts) {
window.adverts.addToArray({"pos": "sidebar-slot" });
}
Sign up to our weekly newsletter
Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox!
We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist
events and special offers.
Sign up