The Supreme Court of Canada has agreed to hear a case about whether it’s constitutional for police to make a random traffic stop without reasonable suspicion the driver has committed an offence.
Canada’s highest court announced Thursday it has granted the Quebec government leave to appeal a lower court decision that said random stops lead to racial profiling.
Get daily National news
Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day.
Sign up for daily National newsletter
Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.
The case involves Joseph-Christopher Luamba, a Montrealer of Haitian descent who said he had been stopped by police nearly a dozen times without reason, including several times when he was behind the wheel. None of the stops resulted in a ticket.Quebec Superior Court Justice Michel Yergeau sided with Luamba in October 2022, saying that racial profiling exists and that it’s a reality that weighs heavily on Black people.
Trending Now
Diana Fox Carney: Hockey player, economist — and the prime minister’s wife
Canada election: Live results from the 2025 vote
The Quebec government appealed the ruling, arguing that it deprived police of an important tool to stop crime, but the Court of Appeal upheld Yergeau’s decision. Story continues below advertisement
if ( typeof( gn_monetize ) !== 'undefined' && typeof( gn_monetize.Ads ) !== 'undefined' && gn_monetize.Ads.initialRequestMade() ) {
// Ads script has been loaded, create the ad.
gn_monetize.Ads.create( {"sizes":"[300,250]","biddable":true,"id":"gpt-ad-300250-10","lazy":false,"targeting":{"pos":10,"slotid":"gpt-ad-300250-10"},"companion":false} );
} else {
// if Ads script not yet loaded, queue up ad data for initialization.
var gnAdSettings = gnAdSettings || {};
gnAdSettings.ads = gnAdSettings.ads || [];
gnAdSettings.ads.push( {"sizes":"[300,250]","biddable":true,"id":"gpt-ad-300250-10","lazy":false,"targeting":{"pos":10,"slotid":"gpt-ad-300250-10"},"companion":false} );
}
The Supreme Court will be asked to weigh in on whether stopping drivers with no apparent reason violates the Charter, and whether the Quebec judges made an error when they overturned a 1990 Supreme Court decision that upheld the practice of random stops.
More on Canada
More videos
Diana Fox Carney: Hockey player, economist — and the prime minister’s wife
Business owner says Canadians turned off by American stereo equipment due to trade war
Not just Poilievre — these familiar MPs also lost their seats in Canada’s election
Trump says ‘great relationship’ with Canada possible under Carney
Canada election 2025: What happens to the Conservatives now that Poilievre lost his seat?
Fake Lapu Lapu victim fundraiser removed from platform
How the Liberal minority government could complicate Carney’s energy policy
Premiers Houston, Ford blast Conservatives as Poilievre faces uncertain future
Ontario sets date for 2025 budget in economy shaped by tariff threat do sex
Jets’ Hellebuyck gets MVP nomination for stellar season do sex
Food trucks back on the scene in Regina do sex
Migrants at ICE detention facility in Texas spell out ‘S-O-S’ do sex
Stolen car, crack cocaine lead Winnipeg police to arrest do sex
US, Ukraine sign long-awaited natural resources deal do sex
