Schools teaching 'prestige' languages over those most spoken, professor saysBy Charlotte WilkesABC BallaratTopic:Language Learning1h ago1 hours agoThu 8 May 2025 at 1:03amBallarat Rootz Punjabi School students would love to see their language taught in mainstream schools. (ABC Ballarat: Charlotte Wilkes)In short:There is a growing number of Punjabi and Vietnamese speakers in Victoria, but these languages remain widely untaught in Victorian schools.Punjabi is taught in two government schools, and Vietnamese is taught in seven.What's next?Communities are calling for greater language diversity in schools.abc.net.au/news/languages-curriculum-education-schools-punjabi-vietnamese/105213638Link copiedShareShare articleWhen 10-year-old Guribadat Kaur started kindergarten in regional Victoria her parents changed her Punjabi name to Ebu because no-one could pronounce her name.Ebu's mother Raman Preet Kaur said her daughter was "lost" before the change."It was hard — she didn't know if people were talking to her, so we had to change her name to something easy to pronounce," she said.Ms Kaur said if Punjabi had been available to learn at her daughter's Ballarat school, Ebu might have felt more accepted and children and teachers might have been able to pronounce her name.In 2025, things started to change for Ebu when she attended the volunteer-run Rootz Punjabi language program outside of school hours."[Her] sense of identity grows more strong," Ms Kaur said.According to the latest census in 2021, Punjabi is the fastest-growing community in Australia, with about 240,000 people using the language at home.In Victoria, Punjabi is the fourth most commonly spoken language, excluding English.However, it is only taught in two Victorian government schools.Raman Kaur and her daughter, Guribadat Kaur, attending Punjabi school. (ABC Ballarat: Charlotte Wilkes)'Prestige languages'University of Melbourne professor of language Joseph Lo Bianco said languages were chosen for schools based on utility, but also "prestige"."I think it is sad that there is a hierarchy of values that many people have in their heads about what language is worthwhile," Professor Lo Bianco said.Professor Lo Bianco thinks schools should consider what languages students speak at home. (Supplied)"The main Asian languages are seen to have economic benefits, such as Japanese and Chinese."People admire French culture, so there's a lot of prestige attached to that."French is one of the top five most-taught languages in Victorian state schools and is offered at many private schools in Melbourne such as Haileybury, Caulfield Grammar, Wesley College and Carey Baptist Grammar.However, there are only 18,543 French speakers in Victoria, which is equivalent to 0.29 per cent of the state's population.Most commonly taught languages in Victorian government schoolsMost commonly spoken languages in Victoria, excluding English1. Mandarin1. Mandarin2. Auslan2. Vietnamese3. Japanese3. Greek4. Italian4. Punjabi5. French5. Italian6. Indonesian6. Arabic7. Spanish7. Cantonese8. German8. Hindi9. Victorian Indigenous Languages9. Sinhalese10. Hindi10. Spanish"I think there is a case for doing more in Arabic and Turkish and Vietnamese and languages like that," Professor Lo Bianco said.He said changing and diversifying the languages taught in schools was difficult because some people did not value some cultures as much as others."So we can only do it by steadily promoting the value of cultural differences," Professor Lo Bianco said.Fastest-growing communityIn 2018, when Ramman Marupur moved to Ballarat, Punjabi was fast becoming one of the most spoken languages in the regional Victorian city.The following year, the first-generation Indian-Australian launched a free school to teach Punjabi language, traditional dance and religion to help students develop a sense of pride about their Indian heritage.Preet Khinda and Ramman Marupur said learning your mother language is important for cultural pride. (ABC Ballarat: Charlotte Wilkes)The Rootz Punjabi School in Ballarat, which has recently expanded to another site in Geelong, has 20 students.Ms Marupur said the school helped students overcome cultural put-downs, like being teased for wearing "Indian costumes".Punjabi is now the second-most spoken language in Ballarat, excluding English.The teacher at Rootz Punjabi School in Geelong, Preet Khinda, said educating students with an Indian background about their language and culture was important, but it needed to be mirrored by acceptance in the wider community."Our kids feel awkward when they speak our language in a shopping centre," Ms Khinda said."I think people should accept all those things, like cultural identity."I think schools should teach all the young children that we should respect each and every culture's language."Growing up bi-culturalAs "one of two Vietnamese students" in her school, Haylee Hua said she grappled with her sense of identity."People ask you, 'What culture are you from?' or, 'What are you?'" the 20-year-old Monash University student said."They'll assume that you're Chinese."She said if Vietnamese had been taught more widely, it would have made life easier for her, and other descendants of Vietnamese migrants."Having an Aussie being able to speak a few words of Vietnamese would really help," Ms Hua said.She attended an out-of-school Victorian School of Languages (VSL) course every Saturday to improve her understanding of Vietnamese outside of her own home.Ms Hua says seeing Vietnamese taught at school would have been encouraging for her younger self. (Supplied: Haylee Hua)Today, Vietnamese is the second-most spoken language at home in Victoria, excluding English.Worse in the regionsProfessor Lo Bianco said Vietnamese was a good example of a language that needed to be more widely taught in mainstream schools to better reflect the real world."In communities where there are a lot of Vietnamese children and families it's mostly neglected," he said.The Punjabi Rootz School is run by volunteers in Ballarat and Geelong. (ABC Ballarat: Charlotte Wilkes)While the Department of Education offers classes in more than 50 languages outside school hours through the VSL, Professor Lo Bianco said regional and remote communities were still "disadvantaged" when it came to language offerings.Professor Lo Bianco said that for migrant communities in regional areas, having diverse language offerings in schools was a "form of respect" and provided migrants with a sense of belonging."[It's] a way of saying that they count," he said."Schools should know more about who their students are and what languages they have in their homes and their communities."If they can't teach those languages, they should celebrate the fact that the students know them."ABC Ballarat — local news in your inboxGet our local newsletter, delivered free each WednesdayYour information is being handled in accordance with the ABC Privacy Collection Statement.Email addressSubscribePosted 1h ago1 hours agoThu 8 May 2025 at 1:03amShare optionsCopy linkFacebookX (formerly Twitter)Top Stories'He was that toxic': 600 unused posters tell the story of Dutton's failed campaignTopic:ElectionsPhoto shows Backlit photo of a Dutton press conference, his silhouette centred in front of a microphoneAustralia's best sports rights in the hands of a Soviet-born, former oil tycoonTopic:Media IndustryAlbanese to speak with King Charles, Labor factions hash out next ministryLIVEPhoto shows Albanese, at a press conference, raises his hands while speaking.Doctor told Erin Patterson she might need liver transplant, court hearsLIVEPhoto shows A digital drawing of Erin Patterson wearing a pink shirt'Offensive': PM unleashes on ousted Greens MPTopic:Government and PoliticsPhoto shows A composite image of two men wearing suits sitting in the House of Representatives.Related storiesCampaign to have First Nations languages taught in schools gathers pace with Labor promiseTopic:Federal ParliamentPhoto shows A portrait of Isaiah smiling, wearing a denim jacket, a cap and a string of pearls, standing in front of an assembly hall. It's Australia's fastest growing language, but still not taught in schoolsTopic:LanguagePhoto shows a group in a ceremony outside brisbane's sikh templeCODA twins' primary school class has learnt Auslan since kindyTopic:DisabilitiesPhoto shows A young girl points at her laughing sister on a couch. Related topicsBallaratGeelongLanguageLanguage LearningPublic SchoolsTop Stories'He was that toxic': 600 unused posters tell the story of Dutton's failed campaignTopic:ElectionsPhoto shows Backlit photo of a Dutton press conference, his silhouette centred in front of a microphoneAustralia's best sports rights in the hands of a Soviet-born, former oil tycoonTopic:Media IndustryAlbanese to speak with King Charles, Labor factions hash out next ministryTopic:Government and PoliticsDoctor told Erin Patterson she might need liver transplant, court hearsTopic:Law, Crime and Justice'Offensive': PM unleashes on ousted Greens MPTopic:Government and PoliticsJust InWoman with more than 1,000 minions in home wins Guinness World RecordTopic:Human Interest11m ago11 minutes agoThu 8 May 2025 at 2:22amANZ profit rises as NAB boss tips rate cuts and housing boomTopic:Banking18m ago18 minutes agoThu 8 May 2025 at 2:15amNepotism, financial misconduct claims rock Aboriginal land councilTopic:Local Government5m ago5 minutes agoThu 8 May 2025 at 2:29amGrazier recovering from grain silo collapse running for his rescuersTopic:Emergency Services42m ago42 minutes agoThu 8 May 2025 at 1:51amMore Just InBack to top